Are Allium Aaseae and Allium Carinatum in the same botanical family?

Yes — both belong to Amaryllidaceae.

Can you substitute Allium Aaseae for Allium Carinatum?

They are close relatives in the genus Allium, often substitutable with flavor adjustments.

Compare · per-herb profile

Allium Aaseae vs Allium Carinatum

Allium aaseae · Allium carinatum

Allium Aaseae

Allium aaseae

T Traditional Use

Family: Amaryllidaceae
Genus: Allium
Primary use: aromatic

Allium aaseae, the Southern Idaho onion or Aase's onion, is a plant species endemic to southwestern Idaho. It has been reported from 6 counties: Elmore, Ada, Boise, Gem, Payette and Washington.

Allium Carinatum

Allium carinatum

T Traditional Use

Family: Amaryllidaceae
Genus: Allium
Primary use: aromatic

Allium carinatum, the keeled garlic or witch's garlic, is a bulbous perennial flowering plant in the family Amaryllidaceae. It is widespread across central and southern Europe, with some populations in Asiatic Turkey. It is cultivated in many places as an ornamental and also for …

At a glance

· Same genus (Allium) — close relatives, often substitutable.
· Both are primarily aromatic.
· Evidence tiers — Allium Aaseae: T; Allium Carinatum: T.